'No education and training, no registration, no advice', says firm

“All advice should be regulated in a similar way”, a financial services firm has argued in its QAR submission.

“No education and training, no registration, no advice,” Fiducian Financial Services argued in its submission to the Quality of Advice Review (QAR).

Although it believes “greater clarity” on what advice is, would go a long way to formulate how it is regulated, the firm argued that regulations should not be “written or softened to appease groups or cohorts seeking lower standards”.

This argument was particularly aimed at “alternative advice providers” or influencers, with Fiducian arguing that “if we are to give the respect that the profession deserves”, anyone who wishes to provide advice of a financial nature should have completed the educational and training requirements.


“It will lift standards, the number of advisers and ensure quality advice is provided. No education and training, no registration, no advice,” the firm said.

The firm also contended different categories of advice, noting that “advice is advice, and must be full and comprehensive advice that is provided by a qualified financial adviser/planner”.

For this, Fiducian noted, a fee needs to be charged that is “sufficient” to compensate the adviser for their education, specialised training, experience, skill, ability to develop an appropriate strategy, and successful management of their business and staff to help the client achieve their retirement and lifestyle goals.

Whether or not financial influencers (finfluencers), in particular, should be regulated has been at the centre of an ongoing debate — one that former financial services minister Jane Hume often engaged in.

Namely, Ms Hume didn’t hide her sometimes controversial view of finfluencers, referring to them as the latest iteration in a long line of consumers sharing views about financial markets, not unlike “taxi drivers giving stock tips”.

“People have been offering free financial advice or free tips for forever and a day. It used to be in the 1930s what was it they said 'when the bell boys start giving you stock tips it’s time to exit the stock', taxi drivers, whoever it might be, there’s been lots of advice out there from friends, family and strangers for forever and a day, and I think most Australians are sensible enough to be able to distinguish between financial advice and a tip from a stranger,” Ms Hume said in May.

Speaking at the AFA Evolve Conference in September last year, she argued against government intervening, noting that the real threat to advise comes from fraudulent members of the industry.

However, despite her arguments to the contrary, the corporate regulator published an information sheet in March on how the law applies to social media influencers and licensees who use them.

This was widely backed by the likes of the Financial Planning Association of Australia (FPA), which had separately asked of the 47th Australian Parliament to better regulate finfluencers.

'No education and training, no registration, no advice', says firm
ifa logo

Subscribe to the ifa bulletin

Receive daily online news,analysis, reports and business strategies
By signing up you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Website Notifications

Get notifications in real time and stay up to date with content that matters to you.